As the chart below shows, the last quarter (first calendar 2012, second fiscal 2012) was robust with 94% earnings growth and 59% net sales growth. Subject to the usual superlatives, the performance was, again, unexpected by many.
Much of that surprise was due to the underestimation of iPhone sales in China during what is a holiday quarter in that nation. Growth this quarter will be more difficult to estimate. The iPhone is still the most important component but the iPad is becoming increasingly decisive in overall performance. In fact, I’m projecting that the iPad will have the equivalent of 73% of the iPhone revenues this quarter.
Dan and Horace talk about the distinction between what Facebook is and what its value is perceived to be. We touch on both the opportunities and the challenges for social media and how these are reflected in the IPO. We note how and why Facebook integration in iOS might happen. Horace has a few words about China, WWDC, and the future of apps on TVs. It’s all about context.
5by5 | The Critical Path #41: Contextual Inquiry.
Here is a video of my presentation at Mobilism 2012 on the story of mobile phone disruption. Thanks to Peter-Paul Koch (aka PPK) for organizing a great event and allowing me to present to such a smart and knowledgeable audience.
Asymmetric competition | Horace Dediu | Mobilism 2012 on Vimeo
Nearly one third of the time is spent in Q&A, which, even if I do say so myself, is the best part.
Also note the exclusive use of a custom iPad app for wireless presentation (pre-release version of the Perspective App.)
The latest data from comScore showed a few surprises:
New smartphone users dropped to a very low level, below the trend line.
Slightly less than 300k new smartphone users abandoned their feature phones every week during the month. Compared with the 1.5 million per week in November, it’s quite a slowdown.
Penetration growth slowed as a result as well. Only 1.3 points of share were gained by smartphones.
It’s still likely that the penetration will reach 50% by the end of summer this year (as was predicted in 2010).
When looking at the picture above broken out by platforms, we see signs that the slowing in smartphone growth seems to be attributable to a slowing in Android adoption:
A glance at Nokia and RIM’s market values today shows that they are both valued below book. With respect to RIM,
The company’s share price has collapsed in the past year, and it is now only valued at about $5.4 billion, down from $84 billion at its peak in 2008. Excluding its cash and the estimated value of its patents, RIM’s device business and its 78 million subscribers around the world are in aggregate worth less than $1 billion to investors.
Analysis: RIM’s new woes seen speeding loss of BlackBerry users – Yahoo! Finance
With respect to Nokia,
MKM: We are downgrading Nokia to Sell from Neutral following our U.S. retail Lumia model checks. We assume no value for the handset business and no value for the roughly four billion euros [about $5 billion] in net cash.
Nokia Suffers From Hang-Ups – Barrons.com
Three years ago the situation was dramatically different. RIM’s share price was six times higher and Nokia’s about four times higher. Here’s what the market looked like in Q1 2010:
This summary view shows individual competitors in the phone market as well as their combined total volumes. The profitability/volumes/pricing can be visualized as well as margins and revenues.
The same visual summary is presented for the first quarters of 2011 and 2012 below: